About Christian's Coins
Your Local Source for Coins, Bullion, and Precious Metals
At Christian’s Coins, we believe collecting and investing in precious metals should be enjoyable, transparent, and accessible to everyone.
Who We Are
A Trusted Name in Coins, Bullion, and Currency Across Wisconsin and Beyond
Located in the heart of Mount Horeb, we proudly serve collectors, investors, families, and estate representatives throughout southern Wisconsin and beyond. While proudly based in Wisconsin, our reputation has allowed us to serve collectors and investors from across the United States.
Whether you’re looking to buy your first silver coin, build a precious metals portfolio, sell an inherited collection, or find that elusive key-date coin, our goal is simple: provide honest service, fair prices, and a welcoming experience.
Start Today
Looking to sell? Bring in your collection for a free evaluation. Looking to buy? Explore our selection of coins, bullion, and currency.
What We Buy
All Collections Welcome — No collection too large or small
What We Sell
Everything for Every Collector — From beginners to advanced collectors
Our Story
Built on Trust, Integrity, and Numismatic Expertise
Christian’s Coins was founded with a simple mission: to make buying and selling precious metals and collectible coins straightforward, honest, and rewarding. As a locally owned Wisconsin business, we understand the importance of trust and relationships in the numismatic community.
CAC Authorized Dealer
Authorized Dealer and Submission Center for Certified Acceptance Corporation, the industry's premier coin verification service.
CDN Exchange Member
Real-time dealer markets, nationwide trading networks, and current pricing information.
XRF Testing Technology
Advanced non-destructive X-Ray Fluorescence analysis for accurate precious metals evaluation.
Products
Featured Coins & Currency
Explore our hand-selected collection of certified coins, rare currency, and precious metals. Each item is authenticated and graded by PCGS or NGC — the industry’s most trusted grading services.
Certified PCGS MS64 DMPL (Deep Mirror Prooflike), this 1884-CC Morgan Dollar features strong cartwheel luster, sharply struck details, and highly reflective mirror fields. A desirable Carson City issue with outstanding eye appeal and eye-catching contrast. Authenticated and encapsulated by PCGS, this is a standout addition to any Morgan Dollar collection. The coin pictured is the exact coin you will receive.
$1,300.00
Grade: MS64 DMPL
Certified NGC MS64 DPL (Deep Prooflike), this 1884-CC Morgan Dollar features strong luster, sharp detail, and attractive reflective fields with excellent contrast. A desirable Carson City issue with strong eye appeal. Authenticated and encapsulated by NGC, this is a great addition to any Morgan Dollar collection. The coin pictured is the exact coin you will receive.
$1,300.00
Grade: MS64
Certified NGC PF64 Proof, this 1889 Three-Cent Nickel is the final-year issue of the series. It features sharp details, mirrored proof surfaces, and excellent eye appeal. Authenticated and encapsulated by NGC, this is a great addition to any U.S. coin collection. The coin pictured is the exact coin you will receive.
$650.00
Grade: PF64
Certified NGC PF66 Proof, this 1882 Three-Cent Nickel features outstanding detail, mirrored proof surfaces, and exceptional eye appeal. Authenticated and encapsulated by NGC, this high-grade proof is an excellent addition to any U.S. coin collection. The coin pictured is the exact coin you will receive.
$900.00
Grade: PF66
Certified NGC PF64, this 1936 Satin Finish Buffalo Nickel features sharp detail, attractive satin surfaces, and strong eye appeal. Authenticated and encapsulated by NGC, this desirable proof issue is an excellent addition to any U.S. coin collection. The coin pictured is the exact coin you will receive.
$1,500.00
Grade: PF64
Certified NGC PF64 Cameo and awarded a CAC Green Sticker, this 1875 Three-Cent Nickel features attractive cameo contrast, sharp proof detail, and excellent eye appeal. A premium certified example, authenticated by NGC and approved by CAC. The coin pictured is the exact coin you will receive.
$950.00
Grade: PF64
Visit Christian's Coins
Helping collectors invest, preserve history, and build lasting value — one coin at a time.
Helping collectors invest wisely, preserve history, and build lasting value — one coin, one transaction, one relationship at a time.
Why Customers Choose Us
Why Customers Choose Christian’s Coins
Christian’s Coins is proud to maintain relationships with respected organizations and services within the numismatic and precious metals industry.
- Honest Evaluations
- Competitive Pricing
- Knowledge and Experience
- Friendly, Local Service
- Accreditations & Industry Affiliations
These affiliations help us provide customers with trusted expertise, access to industry resources, and professional services that support informed buying and selling decisions.